I’ve been wanting to post this for quite a while now, but never got around to finishing it. Now that I have Jon’s honest account of his attempts to foster community and the frustrations he encounters as the perfect pass (but not a Hail Mary, mind you ), I’ll try to catch it, not bobble it, and run with it like a man with his hair on fire. If nothing else, I hope we’ll end up understanding each other a bit better, with a brick or two removed. It seems to me that despite a few common vacations we don’t really know each other well and perhaps that’s partially because we are on different ends of a number of personality spectra.
I loved Steve Taylor’s songs from the very first. Here, finally, was a man who wrote edgy, provocative, insightful lyrics with a Bible-informed worldview – something I had long thought an oxymoron. He’s the one who put the difficulty of belief into words in his song “Harder to Believe than not to.” I still listen to his music occasionally, as I did the other week on a night drive home out of Zürich, when I was much encouraged to have someone ask me “Are you a principled man” instead of singing of Jesus the Friendly Monarch while I drove along one of the more dubious streets of the city. A long time ago, Steve Taylor wrote a song that stuck with me for quite a while:
Life’s too short for small talk
So don’t be talking trivia now
Excess baggage fills this plane
There’s more than we should ever allowThere’s engines stalling and good men falling
But I ain’t crawling awayI just wanna know
Am I pulling people closer?
I just wanna be pulling them to you
I just wanna stay angry at the evil
I just wanna be hungry for the trueFolks play follow the leader
But who’s the leader gonna obey?
Will his head get big when the toes get tapping?
I just wanna know are they catching what I say?I’m a little too young to introspect
And I surely haven’t paid all my dues
But there’s bear traps lying in those woods
Most of them already been usedI just wanna know
Am I pulling people closer?
I just wanna be pulling them to you
I just wanna stay angry at the evil
I just wanna be hungry for the trueSearch me, Father, and know my heart
Try me and know my mind
And if there be any wicked way in me
Pull me to the rock that is higher than II just wanna know
Am I pulling people closer?
I just wanna be pulling them to you
I just wanna stay angry at the evil
I just wanna be hungry for the true
(Lyrics from Sock Heaven, where you can also find some comments on the song.)
The line that stuck with me most was the aphorism in the first line. Short, crisp, and right up the alley of this teen that preferred heading to the family car with a book instead of chewing the fat at after-church coffee time. Small talk was for the birds. Real Men got to the point, spoke trenchant, concise, necessary truth and insight.
Looking back I see that I only got it half right in several ways (which I suppose exponentially diminishes how right I got it). For one, I might have skipped the small talk, but I also skipped the soul-baring heart-to-heart that was this mainstay of Christian lore but never part of my life. Not talking at all is not a useful substitute for small talk. For another, skipping the small talk and going straight to the marrow isn’t for everyone either.
I think my first conscious hint of that came a while back, when someone I’d met for the first time at a church I was visiting went from introductions straight to asking me what God was doing in my life. I later realized that I didn’t want to answer that question, that I felt violated by it, but I lacked the presence of mind to stop and realize that. Instead, I groped for an answer. It’s not a question I often hear, and perhaps that and my lack of awareness of what God is in fact doing daily in my life was part of why I had a hard time saying anything vaguely coherent.
I could turn it the other way and say that asking a Christian what God is doing in his life is like asking a fish what water is doing in his life. It takes a very alert and aware person to understand what sustains him how. However, that’s dodging what I do think can be a legitimate question.
I say can be because not just anyone can get away with asking it. What God is doing in my life – once I get around to grasping what it is – is likely to be very personal, due to his nature as a personal God. He may be showing me something through failure at work, or through a hard time in marriage, or through the temptations I battle or give in to, and none of the above is something I’d share with someone who just happens to have attended the same church service I did. I don’t think there’s a single person with whom I’d share all of the above – either because it’s not appropriate to share (for instance, some temptations I find wise to keep from Janet) or because I do not trust a person in that area. (Guys, be honest here: how many of you would even admit failure at work to yourself?)
It takes trust to be vulnerable, trust that the other person will have my best interests in mind and be gentle with my soft spots. That means I back off at the first whiff of a judgmental attitude or fixed expectations that won’t allow for my path with God and God’s way of working in me to be unique. That whiff tells me that the surgeon won’t be gentle, and won’t read my medical history or check first if I have pre-existing conditions or am taking Aspirin.
And trust is what, in my opinion, ties back in to small talk. Small talk is what builds a net of common understanding that allows me to know the other person means well, because he has so far. Small talk, in my understanding, is the anesthesia of trust that allows the scalpel of truth to perform surgery without the patient writhing to break free and making a deadly mess of it all.
Of course, too much anesthesia kills the patient, too. Small talk alone kills the soul, or, again in Steve Taylor’s words, “Surface skimmers choke on scum.” I am glad there are people like Jon who see that keenly. We need perceptive diagnosticians.
But along with that, most of us also desperately need skilful anesthesists. Once a patient has emerged from surgery lacerated, bleeding, and in screaming pain, he will never again consent to an operation. For instance, how would you react if someone forced an epidural on you because he was the self-appointed (or perhaps state-appointed) expert? That should make us ask: How much damage have we inflicted because we diagnosed and operated on a patient without his consent and he couldn’t take it without the anesthetic?
So, at long last, I’m allowing myself to talk about college basketball, beauty pageants, Mac versus PC, and yes, the weather.
Just as long as that never becomes all I talk about.
